This is part two in a series — start here with part one!
What cannot be included in a healthcare directive?
Although healthcare directives provide considerable flexibility, they are not unlimited. A healthcare directive cannot override applicable law, require medically inappropriate treatment, or give an agent unlimited authority over another person's life.
The following table summarizes important limitations under Minnesota law:
A healthcare directive is intended to guide medical decision-making, but healthcare providers are not necessarily required to provide treatment that is medically inappropriate, unavailable, or contrary to applicable law.
Minnesota law addresses circumstances in which providers cannot comply with an agent's directions, including certain requirements to notify the agent and allow arrangements for a transfer of care. A healthcare directive should therefore communicate realistic treatment preferences and provide enough information to help an agent make decisions in circumstances that may not have been anticipated.
Who can create a healthcare directive?
In Minnesota, an individual must be at least 18 years old and have the capacity to execute a healthcare directive. The individual must be able to understand and communicate their healthcare wishes when creating the document.
A healthcare directive is a personal decision. An individual should not be pressured or improperly influenced by family members, healthcare providers, or other individuals. The person creating the directive is commonly referred to as the principal.
Who can be appointed as a healthcare agent?
Selecting the right healthcare agent is one of the most important decisions involved in preparing a directive.
In Minnesota, a healthcare agent generally must be at least 18 years old. Minnesota law also places restrictions on certain healthcare providers serving as agents. For example, a healthcare provider generally cannot serve unless the provider is a family member or the directive explains the reasons for the appointment.
A good healthcare agent should:
Understand the individual's values and priorities.
Be willing to follow the individual's wishes.
Be comfortable communicating with medical professionals.
Be able to make difficult decisions.
Remain calm during stressful situations.
Be available when needed.
Understand the responsibilities involved.
The person selected does not necessarily need to be a spouse or family member. The most important consideration is selecting someone capable of representing the individual's wishes.
What are the legal requirements for creating a healthcare directive in Minnesota?
Minnesota Statute § 145C.03 establishes the requirements for a legally sufficient healthcare directive.
The document must:
Be in writing.
Be dated.
Identify the principal by name.
Be signed by the principal or by someone authorized to sign on the principal's behalf.
Have the signature verified by a notary public or qualifying witnesses.
Include healthcare instructions, a healthcare power of attorney, or both.
When does a healthcare directive become effective?
A healthcare directive can specify when the appointed agent's authority becomes effective. Under Minnesota law, the authority of a healthcare agent generally becomes effective when the principal lacks decision-making capacity, as determined in accordance with the statute and the directive. The directive may specify a different arrangement where permitted by law.
Importantly, creating a healthcare directive does not automatically mean that the individual loses the right to make personal medical decisions. As long as the individual retains decision-making capacity, their own healthcare decisions generally remain controlling. This distinction is important because a healthcare directive is designed to preserve personal autonomy, not eliminate it.
Can a Healthcare Directive Be Changed or Revoked?
Yes.
In Minnesota, a healthcare directive generally remains effective until it is changed or revoked.
Under Minnesota Statute § 145C.09, a principal may revoke a healthcare directive through legally recognized methods, including:
Making a written statement revoking the directive.
Destroying the directive.
Communicating the intent to revoke it to at least two individuals.
Executing a new healthcare directive.
Individuals should review their documents periodically and update them when circumstances change.
Examples of events that may justify reviewing a directive include:
Marriage or divorce.
Death of an appointed agent.
A change in family relationships.
A significant medical diagnosis.
Changes in personal values or treatment preferences.
Moving to another state.
When a new directive is prepared, copies of the prior document should be replaced or clearly identified as revoked to minimize confusion.
Stay tuned for our final post in this series where we’ll dig into what happens if you don’t have a healthcare directive, federal law, and why everyone needs a healthcare directive.
Sources
Minnesota Statutes § 145C.02
Minnesota Statute § 145C.03
Minnesota Department of Health, Health Care Directives Questions and Answers.
National Institute on Aging, Advance Care Planning: Advance Directives for Health Care, https://www.nia.nih.gov/health/advance-care-planning-advance-directives-health-care